Whereas I loved the story. The Phantom Menace is all about Palpatine manipulating everything so that no matter what happens he wins, and leads the galaxy inexorably on a path to crowning him Emperor. It's a great big foreshadowing exercise, which a prequel needs to be.
Of course when you're George Lucas you have to foreshadow with the subtlety of a lump hammer. You have to have a muppet babies version of Greedo and tell him "you're going to come to a sticky end you no good meanie".
The difference in tone for me is that the first trilogy is set entirely in frontier worlds: Tatooine, Hoth, Dagobah, Bespin, Endor. The second trilogy is set mostly in civilised worlds like Naboo and Coruscant. We see shopping malls and public transport and factories: it just feels different. It's not so much the action itself, as where the action takes place.
no subject
Of course when you're George Lucas you have to foreshadow with the subtlety of a lump hammer. You have to have a muppet babies version of Greedo and tell him "you're going to come to a sticky end you no good meanie".
The difference in tone for me is that the first trilogy is set entirely in frontier worlds: Tatooine, Hoth, Dagobah, Bespin, Endor. The second trilogy is set mostly in civilised worlds like Naboo and Coruscant. We see shopping malls and public transport and factories: it just feels different. It's not so much the action itself, as where the action takes place.