State of the Union

[rich_jacko]

Is it just me, or are politicians on all sides going about this Scottish referendum business completely backwards?

What they should be doing is holding a UK-wide referendum on whether we should have a federal UK, with equal levels of tax and spending powers devolved to each of England / Scotland / Wales / Northern Ireland, and other things (e.g. foreign policy) remaining central. If, after that, the Scottish Government wanted to hold a separate independence referendum, they could do so with the Scots voting in full knowledge of what was on offer if they stay part of the UK.

Or is that too sensible?

For what it's worth, I'm rather fond of Scotland and would be sad if it became a foreign country. But I think it's right that if the UK stays together, it does so by choice.

Comments

[pharrap.livejournal.com]

If we're going to become small quasi-independent federated states, why not do that under the auspices of the EU instead of the UK?

[longhairedhippy.livejournal.com]

I've got to be honest with you, I would much rather see a federal UK than the half-assed mess we have currently...